As modern engines are becoming more advanced and compact, modern engine oils are also becoming more advanced and efficient. Engine oil makers are not just extracting oil for engine lubrication, they are actually engineering the engine oil in laboratories to eliminate any inefficiencies.
There are many big engine oil players in the market. The two of the most prominent engine oil makers are Valvoline and Castrol.
Although both of them promise top-notch engine oils and provide good engine performance and reliability for modern-day engines, there are certain aspects in which one has an edge over the other. Let us dive into the analysis and conclude which of the two- Valvoline or Castrol should you prefer.
Valvoline is one of the oldest engine oil brands and hence it is a name synonymous with reliability. Castrol is known for good performance under extremely high temperatures whereas Valvoline is effective in medium-high temperatures.
Also, Castrol engine oils are tested to have better longevity as compared to Valvoline engine oils. Castrol boasts of having the best friction-reduction engine oil which provides excellent engine protection and performance.
Valvoline, on the other hand, relies more on simple, but effective technologies to keep its game on a level with other top brands. Generally, Valvoline engine oils are cheaper compared to Castrol engine oils.
| Features | Valvoline | Castrol |
|---|---|---|
| Viscosity | Low - High | Low - High |
| Reliability | High | High |
| Suitable Engines | All gasoline and diesel engines | All gasoline and diesel engines |
| Suitable Models | High-mileage, new cars, and high-performance cars | High-mileage, new cars, and high-performance cars |
| Longevity | Medium | High |
| Fuel economy | Good | Good |
| Exposure to high Temperatures | Good | Exceptional |
| Technology | Dual Defense Additive Technology | Fluid Titanium Technology |
| Value for money | 9/10 | 8/10 |
Differences And Similarities Between Valvoline And Castrol
Crucial Differences:-
Exposure to high Temperatures:
Valvoline and Castrol are proven to perform in a variety of temperature conditions however the difference between the two is apparent when put under extreme high-temperature tests. Castrol engine oil performs better than Valvoline engine oil in this regard.
Technology:
Innovation is the key to big engine oil brands such as Valvoline and Castrol. To keep improving alongside the improving engines is the key to their success. However, both Valvoline and Castrol have an edge over the other in certain aspects.
Valvoline has invented ‘Dual Defense Additive’ technology which is engineered specifically for protection against engine wear and tear, and unnecessary sludge deposits. Castrol has ‘Fluid Titanium’ Technology which helps the engine reduce friction and attain maximum performance.
Longevity:
The synthetic variants of Valvoline and Castrol provide better longevity than their conventional oil variants. This is because synthetic oil is chemically designed to keep its lubricating properties for a longer duration without breaking.
When put through some tests to gauge the longevity of both Valvoline and Castrol, in most cases Castrol was able to retain its oil properties for a longer time.
You May Also Like:-
Valvoline vs Mobil 1 | Which One is Better For Your Car
Kirkland Synthetic Oil VS Mobil 1
Similarities:-
Reliability:
Being in the league of top brands for engine oil, both Valvoline and Castrol maintain good credibility among users. Whether you choose Valvoline or Castrol, be assured that you will not regret using any of the two brands.
Suitable engines and models:
Valvoline and Castrol comply with all kinds of gasoline and diesel engines. However, there are some engine oil types in the portfolio of Valvoline and Castrol which comply with only gasoline or diesel engines. Therefore, please make sure to read the label carefully before buying.
Whether you have a car with an old engine or a new car, or even if you have a high-performance car, both Valvoline and Castrol have a variety of engine oils in their brochure.
Fuel Economy:
Fuel economy is a factor that generally depends on a variety of parameters but generally speaking, both Valvoline and Castrol offer decent fuel economy as per your engine and vehicle type. There are few engine oils in the market that can provide a bit better fuel economy.
Viscosity:
Both Valvoline and Castrol have a lot of viscosity grades and hence their viscosity can alter from one grade to another. Therefore, they have a variety of viscosities, and their viscosity also changes with a change in temperature. Whatever may be the required viscosity of your engine, both engine oils come with mostly all kinds of different viscosities.
Types of Engine Oil:
There are 3 types of engine oil prominently- Fully synthetic, semi-synthetic, and conventional engine oil. Both brands have all kinds of engine oils and overall have a variety of products under each category.
Valvoline MaxLife 10W40 vs Castrol Magnatec 10W40 Comparison on YouTube
Some Important Differences and FAQs:
1) Valvoline vs Castrol Full Synthetic engine oil
These 2 brands have a good reputation when it comes to fully synthetic engine oil. Both deliver comparable performances and it mainly boils down to personal preference. Do not worry though, as you will not go wrong when choosing any of the 2 engine oil brands.
However, Castrol has some added benefits to make up for the additional cost it charges over Valvoline. Castrol has a high viscosity index and it helps the engine oil retain its lubricating properties for a longer duration. Also, Castrol’s Fluid Titanium technology ensures that it reduces the friction between the engine components significantly, and provides extra engine protection as compared to Valvoline.
The synthetic engine oil made by Valvoline and Castrol meets and even exceeds all industry standards for engine protection and performance. The molecules are perfectly similar in size as it is synthesized artificially in the laboratories.
Along with that, it contains superior additives such as antioxidants, detergents, and anti-wear additives. Valvoline has a much greater number of outlets though, which makes its presence almost ubiquitous, and hence easily accessible to most people.
Pro-Tip: Go for Castrol if you need high-performance and go for Valvoline if you need reliability and cheaper engine oil.
Related:-
Valvoline vs Pennzoil | Detailed Comparison With FAQs
2) Valvoline vs Castrol motorcycle oil
When it comes to motorcycles, Valvoline and Castrol offer a variety of choices for all kinds, such as 4-stroke engine oils, 2-stroke engine oils, and fully synthetic, Semi-synthetic, and conventional varieties of engine oils.ButCastrol offers a larger number of engine oils for different kinds of motorcycles.
Valvoline has 3 major engine oils for motorcycles:
2-stroke engine oil: 2-stroke engine oil is engineered for not only 2-stroke motorcycles but also other equipment such as lawnmowers, jet skis, snowblowers, etc. It is made for high revving small 2 -stroke engines. It is formulated to provide protection against wear and corrosion, and sludge deposits to provide maximum performance.
Fully-synthetic 4-stroke engine oil: This is manufactured especially for high-performance superbikes, for protection under stress that the engine goes through when the motorcycle is driven hard and fast. It provides outstanding power and acceleration. Also, it provides great wet clutch protection for super slick gear shifting.
Conventional 4-stroke engine oil: It is a cheaper but effective alternative to fully synthetic 4-stroke motorcycle engine oil. It contains special additives to keep the engine clean and provide good performance for cruiser motorcycles.
Castrol has 4 major engine oils for motorcycles:
Castrol Power 1: It is advanced synthetic motorcycle oil for 4-stroke engines. It has the advantage of ‘Trizone technology’ which provides uncompromised performance and protection to the three critical zones of engine, clutch, and gear.
Castrol Power 1 V-twin: It is an advanced synthetic oil made specifically for V-twin engines. It has been tested and proven effective in Harley Davidson motorcycles. It protects the V-twin from depositing any sludge that can deteriorate the power of the motorcycle.
Castrol Actevo: This motorcycle oil is made for the specific purpose of performing under stop-start conditions and cold starts. Its particles cling onto the engine components so that the wear and tear is reduced during the warming up of the engine.
Castrol Go 4T oil: It is a premium conventional mineral-based oil used for 4-stroke engines. It provides protection against viscosity breakdown and critical engine components to keep the engine fit and fine.
Pro-Tip: If you have a motorcycle, you will find Castrol engine oils more engine friendly and have better longevity.
3) Valvoline vs Castrol high mileage
Valvoline and Castrol high-mileage engine oils are manufactured for engines that have clocked over 75,000 miles on the odometer. When the engine gets old, the clearances (gaps) between the engine components widen and it results in power loss and leakage.
High-mileage engine oils have a higher viscosity and sealing capabilities so that the power loss and leakage can be controlled for better overall engine performance.
Valvoline high-mileage engine oil has ‘Maxlife technology’ which ensures superior working in old engines. It protects the engine from friction and provides good sealant capabilities simultaneously along with being less expensive which makes it an automatic choice for customers looking for good value for their money.
Castrol has 2 high-mileage engine oils in its brochure, which adds flexibility. Castrol GTX high-mileage is semi-synthetic engine oil and Castrol Edge high-mileage is fully-synthetic engine oil. Both provide excellent wear protection for older engines however Castrol Edge is better for high-performance vehicles.
4) Is Castrol GTX better than Valvoline?
Castrol GTX conventional motor oil is a premium mineral oil-based offering from Castrol. It is well known for its engine protection and claims to increase the life of the engine. On the other hand, the Valvoline Daily protection engine oil is designed to exceed industry standards for engine protection against sludge deposits.
Castrol has an upper hand when it comes to diesel powertrains, as Castrol engine oils are expected to perform better in this regard. Castrol has a larger number of products as compared to Valvoline which gives its customers a variety of products to choose from.
However, it is Valvoline whose presence in the US market is dominating so it is more likely to find a Valvoline dealership than a Castrol dealership.
5) Can you mix Valvoline and Castrol?
As long as the viscosity grade (for example- 5W30, 10W30, etc) of the engine oil and the type of engine oil (Fully-synthetic, semi-synthetic, or conventional) are the same, you can mix Valvoline and Castrol engine oils without any worries.
You just have to look in your owner’s manual and check the exact specifications of the engine oil mentioned there, and thereafter you can choose any engine of your choice.
6) Is Castrol GTX Synthetic good oil?
Castrol GTX synthetic is fully-synthetic engine oil that has the advantage of ‘Fluid Titanium´ technology which is very useful in eliminating friction losses.
Friction is the greatest enemy of performance as they say. It results in smooth engine performance with minimal losses and great engine protection. It is suited for high-performance supercars but can also be used for daily driven cars or heavy-duty vehicles.
Conclusion
Valvoline and Castrol have a very good reputation when it comes to lubricants, especially engine oils. Although, both brands are reliable, you should go for Castrol if you want high-performance, extreme high-temperature protection, and friction reduction, and you are ready to pay a premium to get these features.
You should also choose Castrol if you have a diesel vehicle. However, if you want a good overall engine performance, sludge, and deposit prevention, and want a cheaper alternative, you should go for Valvoline.
Choose whatever of these engine oils, you will not be regretting your decision as Valvoline and Castrol manufacture engine oils that exceed industry standards for engine wear protection and supreme performance.